Paleo Brownies (Double Chocolate)

Paleo Brownies

Paleo Brownies!?!?! To some that name is sac religious and in my honest opinion, people are going to eat desserts so my job is to provide them with the healthiest option that exists. Since these paleo brownies are gluten, grain, dairy and soy free I feel like they hit the mark. Much better than taking a box off a shelf and adding an egg. Before I forget, I made an amazing candied bacon brownie recipe which is exclusive to The Paleo Kitchen.

Paleo Brownies

Before I was paleo, I wasn’t much of a brownies fan. Actually all I ate was black raspberry ice cream and pizza. Such a healthy way to live right? I had my fair share of struggles, including my 12 year battle with bulimia so being able to eat paleo brownies with a smile on my face is AMAZING.

When I was working on these, I noticed I had a problem. There were already 10 other brownie recipes on my website. Oops, but in the spirit of fair and equal chocolate eating, I will share them all with you.

Homemade Brownies

Here are all my favorite paleo brownie recipes:

Which one are you going to try second. On top of these double chocolate paleo brownies, hands down my favorite recipe is the Blueberry Espresso Brownies.

Oh I almost forgot, my favorite thing to do with all of my brownie recipes is to slater them with my delicious Coffee Chocolate Frosting. Trust me, just try it.

I have spent a lot of time the past few months envisioning where we are going to take Civilized Caveman Cooking in the future.  I am crystal clear and working behind the scenes here to deliver an out of this world user-experience that is loaded with the best recipes, articles, meal plans, videos and more. We have been posting a brand new recipe every day on Instagram and want to keep you happy.

Is there anything you would like to see from us? More emails, more videos, more recipes? Let us know in the comments how we can best support you.

4.7 from 31 reviews
Double Chocolate Brownies
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
Serves: 18
Ingredients
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 325 Degrees F
  2. In a stand mixer or large mixing bowl, blend your almond butter and eggs to make a smooth batter
  3. Add in the honey and the vanilla and mix well
  4. Add the salt, baking soda, and then SLOWLY add in the Cacao powder (or else you will take a chocolate powder bath like I did the first time)
  5. Now fold in the melted chocolate and banana, and mix well
  6. Grease a 13x9 inch baking dish with coconut oil or whatever oil you see fit and bake for 35-40 minutes or until it passes the toothpick test.
  7. Enjoy
***Disclosure: If you purchase any of the products linked in this post or products through the links on the right side of my page, I receive a small percentage from the respected affiliate programs***

Get our Weekly Recipes

Never miss a new recipe, get them delivered to your inbox weekly.

117 Comments

  1. OMG I just had to thank you for this recipe! I never post on anything but I have tried a lot of Paleo baking recipes since I started this way of life and being an avid baker prior to the switch I was continuously disappointed. Looking at the ingredients I was skeptical and I halved the recipe because I didn’t have 2 cups of almond butter. I checked on it at 20 mins and to my surprise it rose like real baking! The texture and flavour is so awesome I would never know they didn’t have a lick of flour or butter/oil. I would honestly serve these to my non Paleo friends and I’m taking them to work to show them off! Thank you thank you thank you for a new staple in my recipe box! :)

  2. THANK YOU George this recipe is my GO TO recipe from now on. I made these brownies using Sun Butter and Maple Syrup baked in 13×9 pan and they were AMAZING! Big, Beautiful and Total Delight for the taste buds and I might add Gone in 60 seconds :-).

  3. Baked this up last night. I accidentally added too much baking powder and my egg ratio was higher and i ended up with a chocolate cake. Still it was very good! Thanks for sharing!

      1. I’m in the process of baking these for the first time and if the batter is any indication (not that I licked the spatula or anything), they are going to be pretty darn awesome!

  4. I made these today exactly as written and they are amazing! They have a great texture and flavor. You can taste the banana but it’s not overwhelming. This recipe also makes a big pan of brownies!

    1. Great recipe however mine came out more “cake” like – how do I make this more dense fudge style like brownies?

  5. These brownies are fantastic. This will be my go to recipe from now on… but the reason for 4 not 5 stars is I will substitute the banana for applesauce in the future. I don’t like the slight banana taste. but the texture and chocolateyness of these is AMAZING. All with no flour is a winner! THank you.

  6. I just started the Paleo diet a week ago and made this recipe tonight. The brownies turned out awesome!! They are super moist. My kids love them. I’m not eating fruit right now so the next time I will try to make it without the banana. I was worried they would not turn out right without it.

  7. I used a bit of hazelnutbutter, and i used date syrup instead of honey. Had to add 1/2 cup of water because of the syrup. Had no banana at hole, but that was no loss. Lovely recipe, will do it again.

    This really makes 18 servings, perhaps a bit more.

      1. Omg, they were awesome. I very tried 5 other recipes. This one is hands down. I’m not allowed organic raw honey so I replaced with splenda. I didn’t use the banana as I’m not allowed them. I used 100% cocoa chocolate chips. Had to make a few improvisions. Came out moist and fudgy. I saved your recipe. Thankyou.

  8. First of all mister, I’d like to know how this is 18 servings, I’m pretty sure this only makes 2-4 servings ;)

    Secondly, this is great as is and is also a great base to use other mashed up starches, sweet potato being a great one! Has anyone tried to swap the honey for soaked, blended dates?

    Thanks GB! Another winner.

    1. Calories? These are high in protein and only have good fat. Don’t worry about the calories. I figured about 55 calories per 3″ x 3″ piece of which 10 calories is from GOOD fat. But I had to modify my recipe. Because of the Paleo, SCD, and Vegan diet I’m on for the rest of my life. Thankyou George. You’re my sweet savior

      Note; it made a FULL 13 x 9 pan. I cut into 12 pieces at 3″ × 3″

        1. Do you by chance have any other paleo/scd desert recipes? I like to make myself something once a week or every other week. Thanks George.

    2. Wow, I made a FULL 13×9 pan? I’ve tried 5 other recipes, this was the best by far. Making again this weekend. I did use 100% cacao chips as I’m not allowed sugar. The Dr said I could use Organic Raw Honey so I’ll be making with that instead of Splenda. I’m psyched.

    1. I think that would be delicious, but I would recommend cutting the sugar down by a little since the maple almond butter (assuming Justin’s) has some sugar in it already, test the batter for sweetness and add more if needed.

    2. I think that would be delicious, but I would recommend cutting the syrup down by a little since the maple almond butter (assuming Justin’s) has some sugar in it already, test the batter for sweetness and add more if needed.

  9. Too bad that I can not make these brownies, I can have no honey or syrups at all. I always use *Swerve* a natural sweetener. I wonder if I were to use cream ( and Swerve )instead of honey if it would work. Well I will try it- I want to eat those brownies lol.

    1. It definitely wouldn’t hurt to try! One other suggestion I may have for a sweetener is coconut nectar. It’s a low glycemic sweetener that might work for you, if you are able to use that. Let me know how it turns out for you!

  10. I’d like to make these into mini brownie bites using a mini muffin pan, any suggestion on how long to bake them? Should I use the same temperature as original recipe?

  11. Just made these for a second time – used a combo of homemade tahini and homemade pumpkin butter instead of almond butter (what I had), maple syrup instead of honey and instead of banana I used puréed strawberries…absolutely DELICIOUS! Wonderful recipe and thanks for sharing!

  12. These brownies are just too good, can’t wait to share them tomorrow, will certainly brighten up my anatomy and physiology learn!! Was wondering if u could give me protein, fat and carb breakdown please! Thanks and look forward to sampling some more of your recipes

  13. I make these all the time but everyone loves them even more when I use the cakepop maker then dip in melted enjoy life chocolate chips and then coconut sugar. Thanks for the recipe

  14. I came across your website through FoodGawker, where these brownies caught my attention. I was a bit hesitant after reading the ingredient list, mainly worried about texture and gooey-ness. I didn’t use a banana, but was very pleasantly surprised and happy at how these turned out. Hubby and I agree that they are the BEST brownies we’ve ever had and now my go-to brownie recipe. Thank you so much for sharing!

  15. These are fantastic! Even my sugar addicted anti paleo roommate gobbled these down. Thank you thank you, I’ll be making these again. Oh, on a side note, I used a 8×8 pan and had to bake for almost an hour but they still came out great.

  16. Hi George,
    I stumbled upon your website by chance and made the banana bread the other day. It was a hit! My family loved it and couldn’t believe there was no added sugar. Even my pastry chef dad was impressed! I just have a question about this recipe before I make it. I just realised I have no honey or maple syrup… Any other suggestions?
    I also couldn’t find any dark choc chips without added sugar so I bought some dried cacao chips, do you think that would work okay?
    Thanks!

    1. Honestly, I don’t have other suggestions. You can try coconut nectar? But you don’t want to substitute a dry sweetener because it will mess with the consistency.

      1. Coconut nectar… Smart idea! I didn’t use that but will try it next time. I found half a cup of macadamia honey so used that and the cacao chips and it turned out really well! The cacao chips are actually quite bitter on their own because there’s nothing else in them but in the brownies, they were perfect. So it was a good choice when I couldn’t get the chocolate chips (I’m in Australia so didn’t have time to order them online). Thanks for taking the time to reply! Really impressed with all of your recipes :)

      1. Is there any need to cook these for less time when subbing maple syrup for honey? Will the maple syrup make the recipe brown faster?

  17. I think you’ve done it again, George! Although, I do have to say I’m a bit leary on using a full cup of honey. But, I put my trust in you as you’ve never failed me before with any of your recipes. ;) My pantry has an unopened jar of almond butter (crunchy even!) that is just screaming to be made into brownies (and the kids screaming for brownies, too). Now that I think of it: this is so gonna be my Mother’s Day treat for myself! ;)

  18. I have tried to make paleo brownies before and it was just sad, but these were so good! I used the apple sauce substitution and I put that chocolate icing recipe of yours on top! My kids and their frieds loved them too, and they’re pretty picky about their brownies :)

  19. These were awesome- but my kids are not fans of the banana flavor.
    Do you recommend any substitution?
    Thanks
    Diane

    1. Unsweetened apple sauce works a treat instead of banana. I have used it in other paleo recipes.

  20. I’m hesitant to make paleo anything as I’ve had a few bad experiences. My husband and I were very pleasantly surprised at how DELICIOUS these brownies are!! I didn’t have a banana so I left it out and it turned out just fine. I prefer brownies on the slightly drier side and these were perfect. Not too sweet and great with a cup of coffee for breakfast – sweet treat without all the guilt! Thanks for the recipe.

  21. It has been a Civilized Caveman week at our house. Triple B Chili earlier this week. Caveman Rub on our chicken tonight. And now these brownies. Wow! These are incredible. I think I need to hide these from my family so I can keep them to myself ;)

  22. These brownies are great. I’ve already made them twice. My kids love them. I think they are fantastic.

    I subbed a generous 1/2 cup of applesauce for the banana (I hate fruit/chocolate & was worried about tasting banana)

    I was in baking mode today. Made these & your banana bread recipe (which is another one of our favorites).

    Thanks for the great recipes!

  23. I just made this recipe today using cashew butter and it turns out great! We’re enjoying it right now with my daughter and mother in law. You’re a genius! Thanks for this great recipe:)

  24. Ok, I just finished making these brownies and they are out of this world good! I used raw almond butter and tahini. As for the banana, I used an organic one that was actually just ripe and it all worked out! Love this recipe!

  25. I tried the recipe and did not realize I did not have an entire cup of honey, so I used about 1/3 cup honey and 1/2 cup coconut palm sugar. They turned out great! Not too sweet but yet decadent. Thank you!

  26. Ok…I have a challenge for you. How to make these egg-less and get them to rise right. You can substitute eggs, pumpkin, applesauce, etc. for eggs in recipes, but when doing so, they rise differently. I have been making nut/seed butter muffins lately using 1 cup nut butter, 1 cup banana or pumpkin, 1/4 cup honey, chocolate chips, and sometimes cocoa to make them double chocolate…but they rise up and sink in the middle. I have tried using 1 tsp baking powder + 1/2 of soda, but it isn’t much better. Any ideas? I am paleo because I have MS and this diet works best for me, but eggs seem to also aggravate my symptoms, leaving me with some major baking challenges these days. Any help would be very much appreciated! PS: I L.O.V.E every recipe you come up with which makes this even more difficult…you use eggs in like everything…

  27. Ok, now I know what to make for a diabetic “birthday cake” . I’ll just bake it in a round pan, then frost. Can’t have honey with my diabetes, but coconut sugar is fine. Let you all know how it comes out. Btw, When I first discovered you,George I was a brand new type 1. Now for reasons only known to God. I am off all insulin. Thanks! George for helping me be a better mom, a healthier diabetic and to live a long life because of Paleo. Keep up the great work and look forward to getting your cookbook for Mother’s Day from my kids. Good food never goes out of style.

      1. George,
        I’d thought to let you know how the brownies came out. I used 1 1/4 cup coconut sugar and 1/4 cup water to sub out for the honey. The banana taste didn’t fly well. So I will try it without a banana, then with a more carb friendly alternative. Can’t wait for Mother’s Day and your cookbook.

  28. If I was going to sub the honey out for coconut sugar, do I use the same amount? Can’t wait to make these this weekend! Thanks for all the yummy recipes!!

    1. Thanks for the fabulous recipe!! I finally made these last night and they were awesome!!!
      I substituted honey with 1c coconut sugar and it was plenty sweet. The only issue I had was that mine flattened when they came out of the oven. Could this be because I was short on almond butter and only used 12 oz? The texture is perfect, just flat. Also, when I make them again for my son who doesn’t line banana flavor, what can I sub for the banana?

  29. I just love the way you put links to where I can find these ingredients. Being new to the whole paleo lifestyle of eating, I don’t even know what some of these things are so what you do is very helpful. Thanks.

  30. Why don’t you include nutritional info. I am on very low carb but have no idea if I can make these for myself or not. Please include this information on your recipes. They all look so good but like I said I don’t know if I can eat them.

  31. Really, really great texture. I just can’t get past the taste of the banana. Love you George, just not the recipe. :(

  32. you dont know me, but i love your writings and recipes and personality that comes through on your site and email. just wanted to say good job. i really appreciate all the work you put into make our lives healthier. thanks again-

  33. My family isn’t paleo, I am. They wouldn’t make me a birthday cake because “they don’t know how to bake paleo.” So I had to make my own. I made these brownies! YUMMM! Thank you George, they were work making for myself! They tasted just like what I remember brownies to taste like! (just be careful not to overbake. I may need to make them again soon because I think I left mine in about 2 minutes too long. Good excuse to make more, right?! :-)

  34. The recipe was easy to prepare. The texture is awesome because the brownies are moist and firm with a little crispiness on the edges. Overall, they were the perfect amount of sweetness.

  35. OMG these are amazing. I am already 3 brownies in and planning to eat most of the pan soon! My 6 year old is begging for them. They are better than a lot of non paleo brownies I have eaten and will definitely make them again. My husband even likes them and I can see taking them to an event and nobody knowing the difference. LOVE!

  36. OMG made these tonight and they are better than a lot of non paleo brownies. I am in love and I might devour the entire pan! I have eaten three already and am using them to bribe my 6 year old! Definite must try! Delicious!!

  37. These look amazing…might have to throw a little DoTERRA wild orange or peppermint essential oil in there to give it a little twist. Thanks for sharing!

  38. This looks amazing! And I love that it can easily be made nut free!
    I love what your are doing with Civilized Caveman, and I love you! You are such a genuine, beautiful person. Keep it up! ❤️

  39. Wow, George, these look amazing! I’m leaving shortly on a business trip, but I’m going to set aside a banana to get nice and ripe so I can make these when I get home!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Rate this Recipe: