Apple Pumpkin Butter

post banner cavemanfeast Apple Pumpkin Butter

So I don’t know if you can tell, but IT’S FALL!  Well in Southern California where I am.  For some of you it is probably already winter or has been cold for a while.  Either way, I am in Temecula, so I am going to talk about Temecula.  Let me start by saying in the summer and up to about a week ago, it was hotter than the devil’s ass-crack.  I wish I was being facetious, but I have electric bills which can validate my claim from my attempts to keep it under 80 degrees in my house. Moot point, but I am just leading into my excitement that I am sitting here in my all-tim- favorite outfit typing away slightly chilly.  Any guesses on my favorite outfit?  I have talked about it before…….Yep, that’s right.  Hollister baggy sweat pants with an oversized Barbells for Boobs hoodie I won last year.  This hoodie is the shiznit. I swear I could wear it in the arctic, but I am not going to try.  You should support the boobies. I sure do. It’s the right thing to do, so go check out their site.

Applepumpkinbutter Apple Pumpkin Butter

I apologize if you are reading this second paragraph.  Why you ask, because I subjected you to my random rants in the first one that have absolutely nothing to do with this recipe, or do they?  That’s right, I am going to try and tie them together.  Here goes my logic……I opened up with talking about the crappy heat and I exaggerated to make you feel all hot.  Did it work?  Probably not, but then I brought it back and talked about being all cozy in my sweats and how I could use my ridiculously comfortable hoodie in the arctic.  Did you get cold?  If not, you should have, so humor me and pretend you did.  Pretending is good for us, it keeps us young and our imagination sharp.  Off-topic but I think I just made a very important statement about life.  Let go of some of the superficial crap we let get to us everyday, and just get back to being jovial and free spirited for a minute.  Do you remember when we were kids? We had no cares in the world except climbing a tree, or when the next game of dodge-ball or red rover was.  It was such a happier time.

20121009 ApplepumpkinButter016 Apple Pumpkin Butter

I realize that I just threw a mind maze at your with the spaztastic topics I covered in one paragraph that made no sense in any language.  Sorry but that is just how my brain works when I am typing.  I will try and tie them together here.  Ready? So I mentioned the arctic to make you cold, you pretended you were cold (’cause we are awesome and pretending is fun) and now you are going to go make this recipe to warm you up or to fill your house with the rich and smooth aroma of baking apples.  So if it all works correctly, you went on a non-climate-controlled rollercoaster to make you want this recipe.  If it didn’t work, you are just laughing your ass off trying to figure out how my brain works, which is ok too.  Either way I made you smile. Now, go pay it forward.  While I am at it too, once you are done reading and you are making this recipe, while it’s cooking, DO SOMETHING DIFFERENT.  Shut your phone off, close your email, forget about Facebook, and go outside and do something you haven’t in 10 years.  Go climb a tree, skip up and down the  block or just go for a walk in the park.  You will be surprised at how amazing it feels, I promise.  Then come back and tell me what you did and how this recipe made you happy when you were done.  Please.

4.8 from 8 reviews
Apple Pumpkin Butter
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
Serves: 4
  1. Line the bottom of your crockpot with your apples
  2. In a mixing bowl, combine pumpkin, coconut milk, pecans, vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves
  3. Mix well and pour this mixture over your apples in the crockpot
  4. Set on low and let cook for a minimum of 6 hours or high for 3 hours
  5. You can serve as is or using an immersion blender or food processor, blend it into a smooth butter
You can serve this as is, or serve with some Pumpkin Butter Cups or on some Muffins

****Disclosure: If you purchase any of the products linked in this post or products through the links on the right side of my page, I receive a small percentage from the respected affiliate programs****

Email subscription

Never miss a new recipe, get them delivered to your inbox weekly

arrow orange Apple Pumpkin Butter

 Apple Pumpkin Butter  Apple Pumpkin Butter  Apple Pumpkin Butter  Apple Pumpkin Butter


  1. Is there any way I can make this without a crock pot? I will get one in the near future, but I just really wanted to try this recipe! Hoping to make it for a “tea party” themed birthday party as a scone topper.

    Would I be able to simmer this on very low in a deep pot? Thanks!!

  2. How would one can this recipe? Or is that possible? I want to give as shelf-stable Christmas gifts.

  3. Making this for the third time today… still one of my favorite recipes.

  4. OMGoodness!!! This is so good!! I made this last night. Luckily I have 2 crockpots. I had some pears from my mother-in-law’s house, she has pear trees growing wild at her house, that were in need of being used so I made an apple batch and a pear batch!! I did add some extra honey, I like it a tad bit sweeter than the recipe called for. I left the skins on the apples and the pears since I was blending this in my vitamix, why lose those nutrients if I don’t have to? I took some to work and it was a huge hit! I see christmas gifts made of this stuff!! Thank you for sharing! I love your recipes, and I’ve already preordered you next cookbook!

  5. Angie Bryant says:

    Made this a year ago. Ate some and froze some in Mason jars. Thawed it and ate it tonight and it was just as amazing.

  6. Any reason you couldn’t use apple juice or cider rather than coconut milk?

  7. Liz Overton says:

    How long would this keep in the refrigerator?

  8. Have this is the crockpot now! I made a double batch. My question is, do you think I could freeze extra jars of it? I wanted to make enough to last for a bit but was unsure how to save it? Would freezing be best?
    Thanks for the great recipe! I look forward to trying it in the morning!

  9. Silly question – after making should I refrigerate? I plan on making it as a gift (in jars) and don’t want it to spoil :) sitting on the counter for a few hours during a party and want to hand out as favors. thank you!

  10. If I am just using apples and no pumpkin, do I still add the coconut milk? Thanks!

  11. Has anyone tried this with pears? I wonder if it would get too mushy. My nutritionist says I have a food sensitivity to apples :(

  12. KelseyB says:

    I made this with unsweetened almond milk and a couple of walnuts instead of the pecans, and half the vanilla (I can never resist making minor adaptations!) and it was absolutely beautiful. I am on an SCD diet, so I’ve been having it for breakfast mixed in with the SCD yoghurt, and sneaking spoonfuls of it all my itself for snacks! Thanks for this beautiful, simple recipes.

    Will be trying with a bit more pumpkin next time, just to see how it turns out :)

  13. Heather Huston says:

    Can this be made without nuts?


  14. Samantha says:

    Tastes great on its own! Excited to try it on a muffin.

  15. KelleyB says:

    Do you use canned coconut milk or boxed coconut milk?

  16. I’m new to the blog, and live in the Temecula area as well. I can’t wait to try all these recipes!

  17. My husband and I are making the lifestyle change to Paleo in the end of January due to moving across the country and we don’t have anything in our house. This will be on the top of the list for must makes, I can’t wait to explore the rest of your site for recipes.

  18. So I made this pureed it, and now have NO idea what to do with it. *facepalm*. Muffins are NOT Paleo. I’m thinking either dipping apples in it or cooking chicken in it. any other ideas??

  19. O.M.G. That was amazing! I imagine I wasn’t supposed to eat the whole thing in 2 days but WOW! I went middle of the road and used a potato masher. So good warm. So good cold. So good! Thanks George!

  20. I think I may have to invest in a second crockpot…there’s a roast in mine right now…

    • THat is why I have 5 of them :)

      • No way…dude…really? OMG…I don’t have room for the one that I have, but with all this crockpottin’ goin’ on, I’m going to need at least one more! :) Oh, since you have five, are they all the same, oval, round, do you have different brands? Which one is your favorite? Might as well do a little research on the subject before I buy another, in case there’s a better option than the standard Rival Crockpot. :D

  21. Made this last night….AMAZING!! Pretty sure I’ve died and gone to paleo heaven!!

  22. Almond Joy says:

    I’ve been planning this for us all week, knowing we’d be up late election night, I started up the crockpot about 11pm. we woke up about 6:30am and my house smells as good as Christmas morning! We used chopped almonds instead of pecans and my kids and I are enjoying it with a side of bacon! It’s nice and soft (I feel like Mushy implies Ick) and we chose to not blend it up and enjoy it as a ‘Paleo’ oatmeal type of breakfast. Thanks for the pretty pics and easy recipe! Next time I may have to double it, you really want seconds of this one!

  23. I LOVE FLAVORED BUTTERS!!!! I think that this will come into my dreams pretty quick, alongside some whole-wheat honey rolls or something! LOVE IT! ~

  24. Could you make this with Almond Milk? I don’t like coconut milk.

  25. In Australia we don’t have ready made pumpkin puree… I usually just make it myself but in this case do you think it would be soft enough if I just put pumpkin pieces in with the apple pieces and blended it all at the end?

  26. Wow! I stumbled onto your site just in the neck of time. After a recent diagnosis of Type 1 diabetes my body won’t tolerate any grains, legumes, starchy vegetables or sugar. Going from milling wheat and cooking just about everything from scratch to a grain free kitchen in less than a month. Thanks for making the transition more fun than I thought possible. Even my husband and kids are happy with the food. Now I can doing something with the last 60 pounds of apples other than quarts of applesauce. About Temecula, at least it isn’t Edwards AFB, its pretty hot here too!

  27. Stop–you’re all making me envious!! It’s been getting colder and colder here since September (I’m in the Toronto area). It didn’t get above 41F here all weekend–and it snained! (Rain and snow all at once). I was at the cottage and was unwilling to leave the cottage once, for anything. Ok, well, I went for a canoe paddle when the sun came out, but the wind made my knuckles beet red. Had to wade barefoot into the lake to wash my dog who rolled in something and it was 33F. It was bone-achingly cold. Well, George, you can just keep on churning out the cold weather recipes right through until April because up here, we’ll just be hibernating and living for every one of those cinnamon-y things you can create. I’m making this one friday night–to put on saturday morning paleo pancakes.

  28. Sharon D. says:

    I am in east San Diego County and no one else understands how we suffer here…………..90′s again today………Fall, where are you!?!??!?

  29. STOP IT! I cannot resist this recipe. I think I’m going to make it continuously for a week just to smell it!!!! Gonna tell you right now I’m eating this with vanilla ice cream. Copious, copious amounts of ice cream.

  30. 1) can’t wait to try this! apple butter is one of the few things i miss from my former Non Paleo days…..can’t wait to try this…

    AND? I totally agree on the barbells for boobs hoodie! I adore that thing….cept i live in Texas and don’t get to wear it all that often!

    glad to have ‘found ‘you….

  31. Looks delicious!!!!!!!! How long and at what temp wold you make this in the oven?

    • Tricia,

      I didn’t experiment with it in the oven, I would say cover it at 350 and start with 45 mins to an hour. Check it often but you need it to be almost mushy

      • Thanks George. This looks like a great option for my kids breakfast as it gets cold.
        Also gotta tell you – we have special birthday dinners at our house – the birthday persons choice. This year my husband wanted your beef bacon butternut squash!!! So yummy!! Butternut squash is not readily available where we live so it was hard. Mixed it with acorn squash – just not the same.
        Thanks for all the great recipes!!!!!

  32. Julia McCabe says:

    OMG!!! Making this TODAY!!!! Minus the Pecans but I will be adding Mac Nuts!!! (I am a MAC NUT FREAK!!!) ;) Thank you for being SO AMAZING!!!!!

    Thank you for the reminder to Do Something Different today!!! :)

  33. julie hagglund says:

    What do you have pictured here? It looks amazing? Is it the butter on something?

  34. Nom!!! This sounds delicious! I just got a new crockpot, and I think this may be the first thing I make in it.

Speak Your Mind


Rate this Recipe: